We caught up with VSO’s Responsible Volunteering Specialist, Clare Hawkes, a long-term volunteer who teamed up with ICS volunteers in Cambodia. Find out how they're working together to raise awareness about orphanage ‘voluntourism’ and responsible volunteering.
My passion was kickstarted by visiting an orphanage
Currently in Phnom Penh on a two-year placement with Voluntary Service Overseas (VSO), Clare found her passion for responsible volunteering while on two previous VSO placements – kickstarted by a trip to a local orphanage.
“I volunteered for VSO in Nepal from 2005 to 2007 and then again from 2014 to 2016. It was in Nepal I became aware of the problems around orphanages and voluntourism after I visited a friend who was working in an orphanage close by.
“She talked to us about all the concerns she had and how as she was finding out more about the children, they weren’t orphans at all. Most of the children actually had parents and had been brought into the city from remote hill regions,” she added.
Orphanages in Nepal, Cambodia and many other parts of the world are under long-standing criticism. Eighty percent of children in these institutions have at least one living parent and although decades of research has shown that children are better cared for within a family setting, money and volunteers continue to flow into orphanages.
Orphanages are expanding to satisfy the demand
The issues surrounding voluntourism and orphanages arise where institutions often attempt to meet the growing demand for voluntary work. The high demand for voluntary placements within orphanages means that there are not enough children to satisfy the demands within the institutions. As a result, new orphanages are opening their doors and encouraging vulnerable families to place their children in care, opening them up to serious harm.
We recognise the valuable and compelling academic research that demonstrates the detrimental impacts that volunteer contact can have on institutionalised children.Philip GoodwinCEO, VSO
Volunteers who lack the proper skills, experience and background checks to work with young children add further to the risk for these already vulnerable children.
“VSO has been working with volunteers for nearly 60 years to help address poverty and social exclusion across the globe," said Phillip Goodwin, CEO of VSO.
"We recognise the valuable and compelling academic research that demonstrates the detrimental impacts volunteer contact can have on institutionalised children.
"This is why VSO does not support such placements.”
Resettling children trafficked into orphanages
Following Clare’s visit to the orphanage in Nepal, she became increasingly aware of the work carried out by Next Generation Nepal, a charity which works to resettle children living in orphanages with their families. Clare researched the detrimental impacts that orphanages can have on young children. She found that whilst orphanages can be necessary as a short-term solution following a crisis, they should not be viewed as a long-term solution and children should stay with their families wherever possible.
So why does it happen?
Chakreya Bout is a national volunteer and works alongside Clare in VSO’s Phnom Penh office. She highlighted the harmful nature of orphanages in countries such as Cambodia and why parents in difficult circumstances face no choice but to send their children to such institutions.
“Parents who are in extreme poverty often think that they have no choice but to send their children to orphanages, where their children can access a free education. However, it’s more complicated than this. Extensive research highlights that children’s development can really suffer if they are placed in these institutions,” Chakreya said.
“First and foremost, we should focus on supporting communities and families - the root of the problem.
“Working with VSO Cambodia, I want to inspire people to carry out volunteer work, whilst raising awareness about responsible volunteering. In the future, I hope to see responsible volunteering as the main concern when people are thinking about doing a volunteer placement.“
"And that's when the importance hit home"
It’s here in Cambodia where Clare and Chakreya teamed up with ICS volunteers, including Daphne Tapfumaneyi, to raise awareness surrounding the importance of responsible volunteering. This was carried out through different projects, including campaign videos and through volunteers’ Action at Home.
The ICS volunteers were so enthusiastic. It’s so important to have them on board.Clare HawkesResponsible volunteering specialist, VSO Cambodia
Daphne, 27, is from Luton and volunteered with ICS in Cambodia. She worked with Clare and other volunteers to help spread the message on ways to ensure positive impacts when working with local communities.
“I met Clare at an annual conference in Cambodia. She’s so inspirational and became a support network for us all. When she came to visit us to ask if we wanted to get involved in raising awareness for responsible volunteering, we were all really up for it and that’s when the importance of the work really hit home," said Daphne.
“She did a training session for volunteers on responsible volunteering and we learnt more about deterring people from volunteering in orphanages and it brought on discussions around what is good and bad volunteering."
So, what is Clare's advice to make sure you're volunteering responsibly?
“What you need to ask yourself before taking part in any voluntary work is: is this voluntourism, or am I going to be volunteering in a community-driven development project? Why do they want me to be involved? When I finish the placement, what am I handing over or leaving behind?" said Clare.
“I’ve seen some really amazing work being carried out by ICS volunteers. They’re raising awareness and mobilising the community about important issues like sexual health and inclusive education. I’ve also seen case studies where young people have helped start small businesses or helped to diversify what they’re producing to make a higher income. With these examples, you’re leaving knowledge in communities to improve chances.”
J.K. Rowling took to Twitter this week to speak out against the practice of volunteering in orphanages and against poorly managed “voluntourism” placements – and I’m really glad she did. Writes VSO CEO, Philip Goodwin
Since 2011, more than 38,000 young people have taken part in ICS. Eight years later, we celebrate eight of our favourite moments of ICS impact.